Financing Health in Africa - Le blog
  • Home
  • Bloggers
  • Collaborative projects
  • Join our COPs
  • Resources
  • About Us
  • Contact Us

Informal payments and other failures in health care provision in public facilities: more than just an association?

3/7/2018

3 Commentaires

 
Hyacinthe Kankeu
French version here

Last year, a Working Group on corruption in health services in Africa was created on Collectivity. After a first blog by Juliette Alenda on the challenges of defining petty corruption,  we present here the results of the second strand of our  activity: an empirical analysis covering more than thirty African countries.
 
The issue of informal payments in the relationships between patients and health staff remains little studied/documented in African countries, whether from the perspective of petty corruption (emphasis on illegality) or undue user fees (emphasis on informality). Beyond the diversity of definitions and approaches found in the literature (see the previous blog), the limited data available on this phenomenon, shows that it is a real scourge in several countries. The existence of informal payments (we will use this expression rather than petty corruption in this blog post) is not only an additional financial barrier to accessing care for the poorest in particular, it is also an added problem on top of the many other dysfunctions that characterize the health systems of several low- and middle-income countries.
Photo
Hyacinthe Kankeu
This blog post presents the evolution of the extent of informal payments in public health facilities of several African countries, and explores the possible explanations for their coexistence with other failures in health care provision, using data from Afrobarometer surveys (rounds 3, 5 and 6). As a reminder, since 1999, Afrobarometer surveys have been conducted every two to four years (depending on the country) by a research network made of individuals and institutions/organizations mainly based in Africa. The surveys are primarily aimed at producing data on national public attitudes on democracy and governance in Africa, in order to measure the social, political and economic atmosphere in those countries. The samples range from 1200 to 2400 respondents.

The objective of this brief study is to lift the veil on certain aspects of informal payments by mobilizing databases that are freely accessible to the public, in order to put a figure on this intrinsically diffuse phenomenon. The goal is to create an interest in taking this issue into account, among all the actors involved in improving the performance of our health systems.  
 
1. Level and evolution of informal payments in public hospitals and health centres in Africa

A picture of the situation in 2005-2006, 2011-2013 and 2014-2016 as presented in Figure 1 highlights various profiles for African countries with regards to the extent of the phenomenon. In countries like Botswana and Mauritius, it is almost non-existent, while it is a real problem in Cameroon, Egypt, Guinea, Liberia, Morocco, Sierra Leone, Sudan, and Uganda for example. Looking at the evolution over time, there is a general downward trend between round 5 (2011-2013) and round 6 (2014-2016), with the exception of a few countries (Algeria, Benin, Ghana, Liberia, Malawi and Nigeria). It is also important to note that between these two rounds of surveys, the percentage of individuals who reported having to pay bribes to access care in the public sector has been halved or more than halved in one-third of the countries (Botswana, Burkina Faso, Burundi, Cape Verde, Guinea, Kenya, Madagascar, Niger, Senegal, Sierra Leone, South Africa, Swaziland and Zimbabwe). However, the scale of the problem remains worrying in about 10 countries where more than 20% of those interviewed had to pay informal payments in public health facilities.


Photo

This diversity of profiles and trajectories between countries probably reflects their contextual and structural differences (different general climate of corruption, differentiated development/implementation of health insurance or free care policies, disparities in the level of public expenditure on health, etc.) that would be interesting to study, whether from the point of view of research or evaluation of public policies.

2. Links with other failures in health care provision

In round 5 of the Afrobarometer surveys (2011-2013), people were also interviewed about the other problems they faced in public health facilities. The data presented in Figure 2 shows that in 25 out of the 34 countries covered, more than half of the citizens reported having faced absenteeism of doctors in their public hospital or health centre. The percentage varies from 23.3% in Burundi to 90.4% in Morocco. As for stock-outs of medicines and other medical supplies, apart from Mauritius where only 20.2% of interviewees reported having faced this problem, in all other countries it was very recurrent (between 44.5% in Ghana and 88.9% in Morocco). The problem of long waiting times in public health facilities was even more frequent, with more than 6 out of 10 people reporting having faced this difficulty at least once in the past year in all countries (from 61.1% in Ghana to 94.7% in Morocco), except Mali (51%). Finally, issues such as a lack of attention or respect from health staff (from 34.5% in Mali to 90.6% in Morocco) and dirty hospitals and health centres (15 2% in Cape Verde and 90.2% in Morocco) are also worrying.

Photo

A previous study (1) (at the individual level) has shown that people who report having faced these dysfunctions (absent doctors, drug stock outs and long waiting times) in public health facilities were also more likely to report having had to pay bribes.

Similar patterns emerge when the data is aggregated at the national level. Indeed, Figure 3 shows that countries with high proportions of individuals reporting having paid bribes in public hospitals and health centres are also those where:
  • high proportions of individuals report having faced doctors’ absenteeism (r = 0.62, p-value = 0.0001);
  • high proportions of individuals report having faced stock outs of drugs and other medical supplies (r = 0.56, p-value = 0.0006);
  • high proportions of individuals report having experienced long waiting times (r = 0.30, p-value = 0.0825);
  • high proportions of individuals report having faced lack of attention/respect from medical staff (r = 0.58, p-value = 0.0003);
  • high proportions of individuals report having faced insalubrity in these health facilities (r = 0.61, p-value = 0.0001).
Photo

These stylized facts can be interpreted in two ways: (i) the existence of informal payments is just one of the many health systems failures or (ii) it is a consequence of these dysfunctions. The first explanation, that of simple correlation, would reflect the fact that the coexistence of informal payments and other problems like doctors’ absenteeism or stock-outs of drugs are jointly determined by other factors that are internal or external to health systems (e.g. chronic underfunding of health facilities). The second interpretation is more frequent in the (economic) literature and refers to the fact that informal payments arise from the existence of other problems. Here, the explanation is that actual or fictitious shortages of human and material resources (in face of patient needs) create incentives for patients to pay more for the services they are seeking, including paying informally. A scarcity of quality services leads to an increase in prices. Based on the failures of health systems (shortages being their main manifestation) in some Eastern and Central European countries after the communist era, Gaal and MacKee (2004) have developed a theory - INXIT - around this explanation (2). For them, informal payments are a behavioural reaction to these difficulties, especially when the channels of EXIT (i.e. the existence of alternatives) and VOICE (i.e. the possibility to protest) are blocked. Moreover, in a qualitative study conducted in Tanzania, Maestad and Mwisongo (2011) found that informal payments were the result of rent-seeking activities of health workers who create artificial shortages or voluntarily reduce the quality of care provided to patients to nudge them to make additional payments (3).

In conclusion, the data from Afrobarometer surveys highlight various profiles and evolutions of some 30 African countries with regard to the issue of informal payments in public health facilities. The data also shows a worrying situation in all of these countries, particularly when dysfunctions such as doctors’ absenteeism, stock-outs of drugs, long waiting times, lack of attention/lack of respect from health staff, and insalubrity in public hospitals and health centres are examined. Basic bivariate analyses show strong correlations - at the national level - between the extent of these dysfunctions in health care provision and the magnitude of informal payments. While it is not possible to conclude on the existence of a causal relationship, elements from the existing literature on the topic strongly suggest this possibility. This question deserves further investigation to better understand the underlying causes of the existence of informal payments in the health sector, and to design and implement effective measures to reduce their magnitude and impact on access to health care for the poorest populations.

 
The Working Group on corruption in health services in Africa takes this opportunity to invite readers who have comments, suggestions or explanations about a particular country or group of countries to come forward. As the individual data from Afrobarometer surveys are available, we would like to explore ideas of further analyses that could be generated by this work. Likewise, we welcome any information on other existing databases that would make it possible to study this phenomenon in one way or another in the context of African countries.


(1) Kankeu HT, Ventelou B. Socioeconomic inequalities in informal payments for health care: An assessment of the ‘Robin Hood’ hypothesis in 33 African countries.  Soc. Sci. & Med., 151 (2016), pp. 173-186
(2) Gaal P, McKee M. Informal payment for health care and the theory of ‘INXIT’.  Int. J. Health Plann. Manage, 19 (2004), pp. 163-178
(3) Maestad O, Mwisongo A. Informal payments and the quality of health care: Mechanisms revealed by Tanzanian health workers. Health Pol. 99 (2011), pp. 107-115

Thanks to Juliette Alenda-Demoutiez, Clara Affun-Adegbulu and Bruno Meessen for their helpful comments and suggestions on earlier versions of this blog post.
3 Commentaires
Sharon Wayne
11/7/2020 09:21:52 pm

I want to thank Dr Emu a very powerful spell caster who help me to bring my husband back to me, few month ago i have a serious problem with my husband, to the extend that he left the house, and he started dating another woman and he stayed with the woman, i tried all i can to bring him back, but all my effort was useless until the day my friend came to my house and i told her every thing that had happened between me and my husband, then she told me of a powerful spell caster who help her when she was in the same problem I then contact Dr Emu and told him every thing and he told me not to worry my self again that my husband will come back to me after he has cast a spell on him, i thought it was a joke, after he had finish casting the spell, he told me that he had just finish casting the spell, to my greatest surprise within 48 hours, my husband really came back begging me to forgive him, if you need his help you can contact him with via email: Emutemple@gmail.com or add him up on his whatsapp +2347012841542 is willing to help any body that need his help. 

Répondre
HVAC Contractors Galveston link
9/2/2022 12:44:43 am

Lovely blog you havve

Répondre
Laura Hobson
12/28/2022 11:58:47 am

I was really stressed by Acid reflux issues with my newborn and had consulted Chief Dr Lucky. He gave us a thorough consultation and the medicines were equally effective. In a couple of weeks there was big improvement in my son and we are very pleased with the progress. We cannot thank Chief Dr Lucky enough. Highly recommended.

Email chiefdrlucky@gmail.com

WhatsApp +2348132777335

Répondre



Laisser un réponse.


    Our websites

    Photo
    Photo
    Photo

    We like them...

    SINA-Health
    International Health Policies
    CGD

    Archives

    Septembre 2019
    Juin 2019
    Avril 2019
    Mars 2019
    Mai 2018
    Avril 2018
    Mars 2018
    Février 2018
    Janvier 2018
    Décembre 2017
    Octobre 2017
    Septembre 2017
    Août 2017
    Juillet 2017
    Juin 2017
    Mai 2017
    Avril 2017
    Mars 2017
    Février 2017
    Janvier 2017
    Décembre 2016
    Novembre 2016
    Octobre 2016
    Septembre 2016
    Août 2016
    Juillet 2016
    Avril 2016
    Mars 2016
    Février 2016
    Janvier 2016
    Décembre 2015
    Novembre 2015
    Octobre 2015
    Septembre 2015
    Août 2015
    Juillet 2015
    Juin 2015
    Mai 2015
    Avril 2015
    Mars 2015
    Février 2015
    Janvier 2015
    Décembre 2014
    Octobre 2014
    Septembre 2014
    Juillet 2014
    Juin 2014
    Mai 2014
    Avril 2014
    Mars 2014
    Février 2014
    Janvier 2014
    Décembre 2013
    Novembre 2013
    Octobre 2013
    Septembre 2013
    Août 2013
    Juillet 2013
    Juin 2013
    Mai 2013
    Avril 2013
    Mars 2013
    Février 2013
    Janvier 2013
    Décembre 2012
    Novembre 2012
    Octobre 2012
    Septembre 2012
    Août 2012
    Juillet 2012
    Juin 2012
    Mai 2012
    Avril 2012
    Mars 2012
    Février 2012
    Janvier 2012
    Décembre 2011
    Novembre 2011
    Octobre 2011

    Tags

    Tout
    2012
    Accountability
    Aid
    Alex Ergo
    Assurance Maladie
    Bad
    Bamako Initiative
    Bénin
    Bruno Meessen
    Burkina Faso
    Burundi
    Civil Society
    Communauteacute-de-pratique
    Communauté De Pratique
    Community Of Practice
    Community Participation
    Conference
    Cop
    Course
    Couverture Universelle
    CSU
    Déclaration De Harare
    Divine Ikenwilo
    Dr Congo
    économie Politique
    élections
    équité
    Equity
    Fbp
    Financement Basé Sur Les Résultats
    Financement Public
    Fragilité
    Fragility
    Free Health Care
    Global Fund
    Global Health Governance
    Gratuité
    Gratuité
    Health Equity Fund
    Health Insurance
    ICT
    Identification Des Pauvres
    Isidore Sieleunou
    Jb Falisse
    Jurrien Toonen
    Kenya
    Knowledge-management
    Kouamé
    Leadership
    Mali
    Management
    Maroc
    Maternal And Child Health
    Médicaments
    Mise En Oeuvre
    Mutuelle
    National Health Accounts
    Ngo
    Niger
    Omd
    OMS
    Parlement
    Participation Communautaire
    Pba
    Pbf
    Plaidoyer
    Policy Process
    Politique
    Politique De Gratuité
    Politique De Gratuité
    Post Conflit
    Post-conflit
    Private Sector
    Processus Politique
    Qualité Des Soins
    Qualité Des Soins
    Quality Of Care
    Recherche
    Redevabilité
    Reform
    Réforme
    Research
    Results Based Financing
    Rwanda
    Santé Maternelle
    Secteur Privé
    Sénégal
    Société Civile
    Uganda
    Universal Health Coverage
    User Fee Removal
    Voeux 2012
    Voucher
    WHO

Powered by Create your own unique website with customizable templates.