Financing Health in Africa - Le blog
  • Home
  • Bloggers
  • Collaborative projects
  • Join our COPs
  • Resources
  • About Us
  • Contact Us

Interview with Agostino Paganini (2/2): "the Bamako Initiative died a long time ago"

4/22/2013

2 Commentaires

 
Picture
The second part of our interview with Dr. Agostino Paganini brings us to the evolution of the Bamako Initiative over time and its political feature. Agostino Paganini has an extensive experience of primary health care and emergency health care in Africa, an area in which he has been active for over forty years now.  He was the manager of the Bamako Initiative (BI) Support Unit at the UNICEF HQ. The unit worked closely with African countries that had shown interest in the principles of the BI. In the 1990s’ and 2000s’, he continued to work with UNICEF as a Team Leader for Health in Emergencies and as a country director in Somalia. He has also done senior consultancy work with the World Bank and advises the director of CUAMM (Doctors With Africa).

In retrospect, some people say the Bamako agenda has rarely been properly implemented. In a post on this blog and in an article, Valery Ridde says we me be better abolishing the Bamako Initiative (it is of course a provocation). How do you view the implementation of the Bamako principles until now?

Absolutely. I think this initiative died a long time ago. I think some of the principles are still incredibly valid and some of the problems it was trying to address also still exist. The problem of public accountability and people participation in the management of their health system should be have been better addressed with more democracy but still, it is left unattended in many African countries. The problem of out-of-pocket expenditures with no rules is also still extremely valid. We can call it Bamako Initiative or we can call it the way we want, it does not really matter: some of the problems which the Bamako was trying to address are still there and some of the experiences and principles (some have been applied and some have been badly applied) are still very relevant. But as an initiative, no, I do not think there is such thing as a Bamako Initiative alive at the moment. At least I have not seen anything. 

Would you agree with Susan Rifkin who says that the Bamako Initiative has widened the horizons of community participation? Do you see the current shift from community participation to community accountability as another widening?

Let's be clear, community accountability is accountability towards the community. The difference now is that communities become shareholders. Before they were paying under the table, now they pay and they can ask, what have you done with the money, why have you not done this or that? This is the difference between a vague participatory process and being represented and part of the management of the health unit. And this is something we still need to work on. People have no voice and no exit in low-income countries, except to go to the private sector, but this is not for the poor.

In her recent interview on this blog, Sassy Molyneux insists that we must “carefully consider remuneration and other forms of incentives for community representatives, the challenges of asymmetries between health staff and community representatives in resources and power, and the importance of building trustful relationships”. To me, this sounds a bit like considering the local politics of health. It always struck me how little attention seems to be paid to politics in the BI. We are in a sort of political process, right?

It is political. And not understanding that it is political is the biggest mistake you could do. I think that within the public health community we are sometimes very naïve. We think about supervision and training as the keys to everything but health is political. This is why the US has its health system and this is why Scandinavians have a different health system. Science is science but how science is available as well as the quality of and equity in access to care are political issues. We have to accept it is a though road to get to high quality equitable health care and we are not there yet. There still is a huge asymmetry between the health staff and the people and it is a sign that democracy is not there yet. We need to start from this problem. What I have seen with the Bamako Initiative is a deeply political, not a strictly technical, issue. But of course, people use things and declarations in different ways and they have used this initiative according to their own interests and point of view.

Twenty five years have passed. You have an extensive experience of primary health care in low income countries. According to you, what will be the keys for primary health care in the next 25 years?

What I see coming is more privatisation and more urbanisation. People seem to find in urban areas and even in slums opportunities they do not have in their rural areas. Some countries are growing and establishing health insurance which is an excellent thing I think. At the end of my time working on the Bamako Initiative, we were working on two things (there were two teams). One was community-based monitoring, because data are power. The other was local insurance. Health insurance is a key issue but it is difficult to establish. In many case they start at the national level; yet, in Europe local solidarity mechanisms were the initial insurances.

We need to work on public accountability and equity. These are the two key areas. Are we going in this direction? I am not sure. I think in some countries we are, but in a majority of other countries the private sector is growing as people have more resources and the public sector remains under-financed. What is more, this public sector is very inefficient unless there is public accountability. This is the mixed picture I have. On one side, they are countries progressing, doing very going things. Take for instance the experience of Rwanda with community-based health insurance (French: mutuelles de santé) and new staff remuneration policy. But on the other side, there are many others I think are not going in the same direction.

Any questions I have not asked and you would have liked me to ask or any conclusion you would like to make?

Not really, for me, as I said, it was a fascinating experience. I realised it was also a fascinating debate. Some of the issues are, as I said, very political and some are extremely relevant now. We have to address the relation between the patient, the client and the provider. The current debate of performance-based financing, which is linking financing not to the drugs but to the results, is also extremely interesting. Of course, it will not solve all the problems. I think we should be able to see what the good experiences were in the past and move on, adding on new experiences and new things. Basic public accountability and the role of people is extremely important, good governance of health facilities is very important but result-based financing of health facilities is also very promising if we combine it with other things we have learned. We should not move from fashion to fashion but take the past into account, understand what we have learned and build on it.


2 Commentaires
Rachel Frye
12/9/2023 02:19:04 am

Hello, my name is Rachel Frye and I want to give this testimony in respect of Dr. Odunga who made me win $2 Million Dollars in Lottery by matching the 5 numbers for me. I am happy to be out of financial debt and be able to help my family in these seasonal period of fun and cheer. I contacted Dr. Odunga through Whats-App (+2348167159012) when I told him to help me win the Mega Millions and He told me that it would be spiritually checked if I will win the Lottery. When he informed me that I will not be able to win the Jackpot but I will win huge amount in the lottery I was not completely sad but had great faith in him. I live in Freeland, Saginaw County, Michigan and I would say it was pretty hard to send him the money for the spell before he gave me the winning numbers to play. He sent me the numbers and I played. The next morning after the drawing, I matched the five white balls in the Aug. 4 drawing to win $1 million: 11-30-45-52-56. Thanks to the Megaplier X2, my prize was multiplied to $2 million. Thank You Dr Odunga for this wonderful experience with you. You too can contact Dr. Odunga at his Whats-App +2348167159012 or Email: [email protected]

Répondre
moupay martins
11/29/2024 12:24:27 pm

I was heartbroken because I had a very small manhood , not nice to satisfy a woman, I had so many relationships cut off because of my situation, I have used so many products which i found online but none could offer me the help I searched for. I saw some comments about this specialist called Dr Moses Buba and decided to email him at [email protected] so I decided to give his herbal product a try. i emailed him and he got back to me, he gave me some comforting words with his herbal pills for manhood Enlargement, Within 14days of it, i began to feel the enlargement of my manhood , " and now it just 2 weeks of using his products my manhood is about 9 inches longer and i am so happy, contact DR Moses Buba now via email [email protected] or his WhatsApp number +2349060529305 . contact him through his Facebook page : https://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=61559577240930 may God reward you for your good work . For more info i can help to explain the medication +44 7375301397

HE ALSO RENDERED THE FOLLOWING ........1. BRING YOUR EX BACK........... 2. LOTTERY SPELL......... 3. PREGNANCY SPELL ..........4. WEAK ERECTION ............5. POOR EJACULATION..........

Répondre



Laisser un réponse.


    Our websites

    Photo
    Photo
    Photo

    We like them...

    SINA-Health
    International Health Policies
    CGD

    Archives

    Septembre 2019
    Juin 2019
    Avril 2019
    Mars 2019
    Mai 2018
    Avril 2018
    Mars 2018
    Février 2018
    Janvier 2018
    Décembre 2017
    Octobre 2017
    Septembre 2017
    Août 2017
    Juillet 2017
    Juin 2017
    Mai 2017
    Avril 2017
    Mars 2017
    Février 2017
    Janvier 2017
    Décembre 2016
    Novembre 2016
    Octobre 2016
    Septembre 2016
    Août 2016
    Juillet 2016
    Avril 2016
    Mars 2016
    Février 2016
    Janvier 2016
    Décembre 2015
    Novembre 2015
    Octobre 2015
    Septembre 2015
    Août 2015
    Juillet 2015
    Juin 2015
    Mai 2015
    Avril 2015
    Mars 2015
    Février 2015
    Janvier 2015
    Décembre 2014
    Octobre 2014
    Septembre 2014
    Juillet 2014
    Juin 2014
    Mai 2014
    Avril 2014
    Mars 2014
    Février 2014
    Janvier 2014
    Décembre 2013
    Novembre 2013
    Octobre 2013
    Septembre 2013
    Août 2013
    Juillet 2013
    Juin 2013
    Mai 2013
    Avril 2013
    Mars 2013
    Février 2013
    Janvier 2013
    Décembre 2012
    Novembre 2012
    Octobre 2012
    Septembre 2012
    Août 2012
    Juillet 2012
    Juin 2012
    Mai 2012
    Avril 2012
    Mars 2012
    Février 2012
    Janvier 2012
    Décembre 2011
    Novembre 2011
    Octobre 2011

    Tags

    Tout
    2012
    Accountability
    Aid
    Alex Ergo
    Assurance Maladie
    Bad
    Bamako Initiative
    Bénin
    Bruno Meessen
    Burkina Faso
    Burundi
    Civil Society
    Communauteacute-de-pratique
    Communauté De Pratique
    Community Of Practice
    Community Participation
    Conference
    Cop
    Course
    Couverture Universelle
    CSU
    Déclaration De Harare
    Divine Ikenwilo
    Dr Congo
    économie Politique
    élections
    équité
    Equity
    Fbp
    Financement Basé Sur Les Résultats
    Financement Public
    Fragilité
    Fragility
    Free Health Care
    Global Fund
    Global Health Governance
    Gratuité
    Gratuité
    Health Equity Fund
    Health Insurance
    ICT
    Identification Des Pauvres
    Isidore Sieleunou
    Jb Falisse
    Jurrien Toonen
    Kenya
    Knowledge-management
    Kouamé
    Leadership
    Mali
    Management
    Maroc
    Maternal And Child Health
    Médicaments
    Mise En Oeuvre
    Mutuelle
    National Health Accounts
    Ngo
    Niger
    Omd
    OMS
    Parlement
    Participation Communautaire
    Pba
    Pbf
    Plaidoyer
    Policy Process
    Politique
    Politique De Gratuité
    Politique De Gratuité
    Post Conflit
    Post-conflit
    Private Sector
    Processus Politique
    Qualité Des Soins
    Qualité Des Soins
    Quality Of Care
    Recherche
    Redevabilité
    Reform
    Réforme
    Research
    Results Based Financing
    Rwanda
    Santé Maternelle
    Secteur Privé
    Sénégal
    Société Civile
    Uganda
    Universal Health Coverage
    User Fee Removal
    Voeux 2012
    Voucher
    WHO

Powered by Create your own unique website with customizable templates.