Financing Health in Africa - Le blog
  • Home
  • Bloggers
  • Collaborative projects
  • Join our COPs
  • Resources
  • About Us
  • Contact Us

Bamako Initiative: some concluding thoughts

2/12/2014

5 Commentaires

 
Picture
Jean-Benoît Falisse

It will soon be 27 years that the Bamako Initiative was launched and community participation became a core component of health policy in Africa. Through eight interviews, one personal reflection, and your many comments in French and English, what was once the "magic bullet" of community participation turned out to be a complex topic. The debate is certainly not closed but this blog post series is coming to an end. Here is my own (subjective) conclusion; it brings more questions than answers. 


First of all, the series has put the Bamako Initiative in the continuum of International Health (“global health” we would say today) strategies and policies. The inspiration of the Bamako Initiative seemed a little blurry at first, somewhere between the Chinese barefoot doctors and the 1977 Alma-Ata Conference on Primary Health Care. However, the interview with Walter Kessler shows us how, in the early 1980s, Doctors Without Borders had already set up experimental health committees in Chad and Mali. They would soon inspire the Bamako Initiative. Susan Rifkin and Agostino Paganini explain the relative success of the initiative in its early years, with the involvement of UNICEF in the field and under charismatic and dynamic leadership of the duo formed by Dr. Mahler (WHO) and Mr. Grant (UNICEF). As already foreshadowed by Doctors Without Borders' experience with the health stores in the 1980s, the type of community participation advocated at the Bamako conference came along with the introduction of user fees, which states justified by their inability to pay for everything because of the debt crisis. From its inception, the Bamako Initiative had two faces, which even this series that focused on community participation has not been able to totally disjoint. On the one hand, there is community empowerment and self-management; and on the other hand, there is a more expensive access to care. The question that still arises today, which is answered in the negative by Sophie Witter, is whether it makes sense to continue to link the two?

The Bamako version of community participation -with the health committee as a central mechanism- spread like wildfire in Africa. However, the local context was often neglected, and strategies that worked well in some places worked much less so in others. There is no one size fits all, as illustrated by the contrasting experiences of the DRC where the idea of participation was easily accepted, and neighbouring Uganda where the principle of community health management was going against traditional governance. Once past the initial enthusiasm, community participation initiatives, especially when their support by states or international organisations was discontinued, portended a disengagement of the states vis-à-vis the health of their populations. Community participation cannot be imposed. However, to carry on the idea of "health for all", humanize relationships to health-care services, and develop non-technocratic and holistic approaches to health-care, direct and deep community participation remains a promising track. It is in this spirit that the third recommendation of the recent Dakar Conference proposes to strengthen the capacity of the community to make it a “real partner for the analysis of its health problems, and the planning, implementation and evaluation of health interventions.”

As I write this post, the Bamako Initiative is dead. It has been so for a long time already. Its user fees component is roundly criticized. Its (resource-intensive) community participation component, which has often been hijacked by politicians and was much slower than expected to yield visible impacts, has not been the panacea the global health community once thought it would be. Nevertheless, the idea of ​​giving people a more central place in their health-care system continues to live on. In different parts of the globe, new forms of social accountability and direct involvement of citizens in their own health are taking place. In order to work, these must take greater account of local situations and be of direct interest to the people who are getting involved. The community needs to see an interest in participating. This is basically what the IRC officials, who implemented the Tuungane programme, which generalized a participatory approach to rebuilding communities (and their health services) in Eastern DR Congo, and Dr. Canut of Burundi, who explained how community health workers can become important parts of the health system if they are given incentives, were saying. Community participation cannot be improvised; the example of the ASACO in Mali shows that continued investment and a solid organization are needed to sustain community participation. Once past the naive vision of the community that would ex nihilo organise itself for better health-care, the challenge seems to find ways to encourage and induce participation and maintain it without manipulating it.

In this context, research about community participation still seems in its infancy. More studies are needed and they will probably need to use mixed methods in order to reach conclusions that go beyond the description of cases. It is essential to better understand the link between health facilities and their users. How can we build people's participation? How does it lead (or not) to health improvements? If the process is not linear, how should we report about it? 27 years after the Bamako Initiative, we still know very little about the impact of community participation strategies on health and access to health; especially compared to recent and less recent studies on other major global strategies such as (community-based) health insurance, performance based financing, or fee exemption.

The elephant in the room of this series is the question of power. Community participation is fundamentally about power, which is often disputed among medical staffs, medical authorities, and the population (and within the population itself). Community participation (in health) is not limited to questions that are strictly medical. The Malian adventure, the timing of the set-up of community participation mechanisms in Uganda, or the ASACO system in Mali remind us that participation is political. It is a question of governance. If this were not the case, if the dimension of power was removed from community participation, what we would observe is a pastiche of participation, an empty shell that would quickly lose its appeal. Rather than continuing to avoid the issue of power and call community participation a strictly "technical” question, it is essential to recognize that participation involves the redistribution of power and decisions on the organization and definition of health-care services.

Finally, this series reminds us that there is no magic bullet in international public health. Just like performance-based financing, fee exemption, and all the other ‘grand strategies’ in global health, community participation in itself is not sufficient to achieve health for all. The concept needs to take account of field realities and adapt, and even then, it remains only one element to be combined with other strategies to respond to the many different issues of quality universal health care.


5 Commentaires
Abdel El Abassi
2/12/2014 04:12:42 am

Fully agree with the concluding comments. However I do not think that the Bamako Initiative is definitely left behind. It's principles are still alive and in one way or other being implemented or considered even in the apparently new concept of citizen contend health. Controversial discussion and polemic around cost sharing we're much more ideological rather than fact based considering a specific context and constraint in a given country.

Répondre
Mamadou Diaw
2/20/2014 09:58:28 am

The concept of community participation in the health sector has been highjacked by politicians. Local politicians or their accomplices are the ones at the head of most health committees that are used as plaforms to gain visibility, and leverage to gain political support. Otherwise, it is a sound concept. However, it needs to be evaluated so that the necessary remediations can be made.

Répondre
Rachel Frye
12/9/2023 01:46:11 am

Hello, my name is Rachel Frye and I want to give this testimony in respect of Dr. Odunga who made me win $2 Million Dollars in Lottery by matching the 5 numbers for me. I am happy to be out of financial debt and be able to help my family in these seasonal period of fun and cheer. I contacted Dr. Odunga through Whats-App (+2348167159012) when I told him to help me win the Mega Millions and He told me that it would be spiritually checked if I will win the Lottery. When he informed me that I will not be able to win the Jackpot but I will win huge amount in the lottery I was not completely sad but had great faith in him. I live in Freeland, Saginaw County, Michigan and I would say it was pretty hard to send him the money for the spell before he gave me the winning numbers to play. He sent me the numbers and I played. The next morning after the drawing, I matched the five white balls in the Aug. 4 drawing to win $1 million: 11-30-45-52-56. Thanks to the Megaplier X2, my prize was multiplied to $2 million. Thank You Dr Odunga for this wonderful experience with you. You too can contact Dr. Odunga at his Whats-App +2348167159012 or Email: [email protected]

Répondre
Naomi
9/21/2024 11:23:52 am

I am so happy to testify of the good work of Dr. Grant, I Suffer from Herpes virus since 2020 and I had frequent symptoms in my private area. after some time it will go away after using acyclovir drugs, then come back after some months. it was disheartening since i have been diagnosed, but after finding Dr. Grant and his reviews i was convinced that he will definitely cure me and so i contacted him and he told me how to get his herbal medicine and using it for just two weeks and i will go for check up and first i said how can that be possible but i used his herbal medicine after making purchase and truly i used it and went for the test again, and my result came back negative. so i made it a task to share this good testimony in the internet so that those sick can benefit and get cured. you can contact him on WhatsApp or call: +2348115892498 email: [email protected]

Répondre
moupay martins
11/28/2024 11:54:43 pm

I was heartbroken because I had a very small manhood , not nice to satisfy a woman, I had so many relationships cut off because of my situation, I have used so many products which i found online but none could offer me the help I searched for. I saw some comments about this specialist called Dr Moses Buba and decided to email him at [email protected] so I decided to give his herbal product a try. i emailed him and he got back to me, he gave me some comforting words with his herbal pills for manhood Enlargement, Within 14days of it, i began to feel the enlargement of my manhood , " and now it just 2 weeks of using his products my manhood is about 9 inches longer and i am so happy, contact DR Moses Buba now via email [email protected] or his WhatsApp number +2349060529305 . contact him through his Facebook page : https://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=61559577240930 may God reward you for your good work . For more info i can help to explain the medication +44 7375301397

HE ALSO RENDERED THE FOLLOWING ........1. BRING YOUR EX BACK........... 2. LOTTERY SPELL......... 3. PREGNANCY SPELL ..........4. WEAK ERECTION ............5. POOR EJACULATION..........

Répondre



Laisser un réponse.


    Our websites

    Photo
    Photo
    Photo

    We like them...

    SINA-Health
    International Health Policies
    CGD

    Archives

    Septembre 2019
    Juin 2019
    Avril 2019
    Mars 2019
    Mai 2018
    Avril 2018
    Mars 2018
    Février 2018
    Janvier 2018
    Décembre 2017
    Octobre 2017
    Septembre 2017
    Août 2017
    Juillet 2017
    Juin 2017
    Mai 2017
    Avril 2017
    Mars 2017
    Février 2017
    Janvier 2017
    Décembre 2016
    Novembre 2016
    Octobre 2016
    Septembre 2016
    Août 2016
    Juillet 2016
    Avril 2016
    Mars 2016
    Février 2016
    Janvier 2016
    Décembre 2015
    Novembre 2015
    Octobre 2015
    Septembre 2015
    Août 2015
    Juillet 2015
    Juin 2015
    Mai 2015
    Avril 2015
    Mars 2015
    Février 2015
    Janvier 2015
    Décembre 2014
    Octobre 2014
    Septembre 2014
    Juillet 2014
    Juin 2014
    Mai 2014
    Avril 2014
    Mars 2014
    Février 2014
    Janvier 2014
    Décembre 2013
    Novembre 2013
    Octobre 2013
    Septembre 2013
    Août 2013
    Juillet 2013
    Juin 2013
    Mai 2013
    Avril 2013
    Mars 2013
    Février 2013
    Janvier 2013
    Décembre 2012
    Novembre 2012
    Octobre 2012
    Septembre 2012
    Août 2012
    Juillet 2012
    Juin 2012
    Mai 2012
    Avril 2012
    Mars 2012
    Février 2012
    Janvier 2012
    Décembre 2011
    Novembre 2011
    Octobre 2011

    Tags

    Tout
    2012
    Accountability
    Aid
    Alex Ergo
    Assurance Maladie
    Bad
    Bamako Initiative
    Bénin
    Bruno Meessen
    Burkina Faso
    Burundi
    Civil Society
    Communauteacute-de-pratique
    Communauté De Pratique
    Community Of Practice
    Community Participation
    Conference
    Cop
    Course
    Couverture Universelle
    CSU
    Déclaration De Harare
    Divine Ikenwilo
    Dr Congo
    économie Politique
    élections
    équité
    Equity
    Fbp
    Financement Basé Sur Les Résultats
    Financement Public
    Fragilité
    Fragility
    Free Health Care
    Global Fund
    Global Health Governance
    Gratuité
    Gratuité
    Health Equity Fund
    Health Insurance
    ICT
    Identification Des Pauvres
    Isidore Sieleunou
    Jb Falisse
    Jurrien Toonen
    Kenya
    Knowledge-management
    Kouamé
    Leadership
    Mali
    Management
    Maroc
    Maternal And Child Health
    Médicaments
    Mise En Oeuvre
    Mutuelle
    National Health Accounts
    Ngo
    Niger
    Omd
    OMS
    Parlement
    Participation Communautaire
    Pba
    Pbf
    Plaidoyer
    Policy Process
    Politique
    Politique De Gratuité
    Politique De Gratuité
    Post Conflit
    Post-conflit
    Private Sector
    Processus Politique
    Qualité Des Soins
    Qualité Des Soins
    Quality Of Care
    Recherche
    Redevabilité
    Reform
    Réforme
    Research
    Results Based Financing
    Rwanda
    Santé Maternelle
    Secteur Privé
    Sénégal
    Société Civile
    Uganda
    Universal Health Coverage
    User Fee Removal
    Voeux 2012
    Voucher
    WHO

Powered by Create your own unique website with customizable templates.